fishing on a boat

What to Consider When Buying A Boat

Posted by Jim Mize on February 15, 2019

When you own rural land, you have a place for “big toys”like boats. But how do you choose which boat is best? Outdoorsman Jim Mize went straight to the experts for advice.

variety at a boat show

The variety at a boat show can be intimidating

Walking into a boat show with the intention of buying your first boat can be intimidating. The selection runs from Jon boats with small outboard motors to ski boats that can take up half your yard. Someplace in between is what you had in mind, but how do you find it?

I asked that question of several boat dealers at a recent show and here is their advice.

Bentz Johnson of 72 Marine Sales in Elberton, Georgia, says he starts with a few questions like, “Where do you live? What kind of water will you be on? And what kind of fish will you be after?”

“The pontoon boat market has just exploded,” says Bentz, adding that for non-fishing uses these boats have many advantages. Among these are ease of movement and capacity for people.

Camo aluminum boat

Aluminum boats are lighter to pull and can take rougher handling

“The casual fisherman who goes on weekends may want to look at aluminum boats,” he says, as their advantages include light weight for towing and their ability to take rough handling.

Looking over the fiberglass boats offered, these seem to fall in the category of serious bass fishermen as well as the fish/ski category. Comparing fiberglass to aluminum, several dealers commented that the extra weight of fiberglass gave it a little better ride.

Randy Lee of Lee’s Marine in Anderson, South Carolina, added that price also comes into the picture. Everyone has a budget they need to work within, so balancing price with use is part of the challenge.

Center Console on a boat

Center Consoles allow for standing while driving

Then there are the features such as whether you prefer a center console or like having the steering on one side. That choice, said one dealer, depends on whether you prefer standing or sitting while you drive. Center consoles are usually designed for standing while the side console sits lower in the boat. This choice also affects space in the boat, as middle consoles take up space, well, in the middle.

So with this guidance, I took it upon myself to select a boat based on my uses. First, I considered the type of fishing I would do and the fact that it often involves a fly rod. That means I want an open deck to cast from so I will have nothing to interfere with my line. This ruled out many boats with windshields.

Then, it needs to be stable, as I will be standing to cast usually, so I gave preference to wider aluminum boats or some of the heavier fiberglass boats.

Next, I gave consideration to the weight capacity I would need for people fishing with me. Normally it will be just one or two, but with adults that ruled out anything with capacity under 600 pounds. I found this pushed me into boats around 18 feet in length.

unique fishing boat

The definition of a fishing boat has expanded over the years

I am not in a hurry and don’t plan to fish tournaments, so I can live with outboards on the lower end of the range. In fact, I might troll to search for fish, so idling at lower speeds will be a plus.

Then I turned to some of the less critical features like color, finish and workmanship. Using this process, in just a couple hours of shopping I narrowed my choice to two or three boats. With one last lap, I made my choice.

Luckily for me, I forgot my checkbook.

All photos except top image by Jim Mize.


Land for sale in Florida, Georgia & Texas

Jim Mize

Jim Mize has written humor and nostalgia for magazines including Gray's Sporting Journal, Fly Fisherman Magazine, Field & Stream, and a number of conservation magazines, picking up over fifty Excellence In Craft awards along the way. His most recent book, a collection of humor for fly fisherman entitled A Creek Trickles Through It, was awarded best outdoor book in 2014 by the Southeastern Outdoor Press Association. More on Jim and his writing activities can be found at

Want more from our blog? Subscribe to Rethink:Rural here

Subscribe to get all of our latest content sent directly to your inbox, or contact us directly with any questions you have.

Subscribe Here